Back on the C card you leaned on: chip and handle, status, the Comments and Messages tiles with their trend, gate pills at the foot. Everything except the status treatment is identical across all four, so the only thing under comparison is whether the state reads clearly.
Your axis-1 ruling, applied. No description under any status, on any card. The six words are Not connected · Disabled in red · Turned off · Nothing has ever arrived · Gone quiet · Receiving. Each variant below shows three channels in three different states, so a treatment has to work for the good case and the bad one.
1 · Status is the headline
The state gets the largest type on the card, directly under the name. You read the state before anything else and the numbers are supporting evidence.
Instagram@silveroakproperties
Receiving
Comments
116
Highest in two weeks
Messages
34
None of them answered
Comments liveModeration liveDMs off
WhatsApp+971 4 512 8840
Disabled
Messages
0
Flat for 3 days
Replies canary
FacebookSilver Oak Properties
Gone quiet
Comments
12
Drifting down all fortnight
Messages
—
Messenger is not wired up
Comments shadowModeration shadow
2 · Status on the header line, as a solid pill
The state sits right of the handle as a filled pill. Tightest of the four, and a wall of cards scans down one edge.
Instagram@silveroakpropertiesReceiving
Comments
116
Highest in two weeks
Messages
34
None of them answered
Comments liveModeration liveDMs off
WhatsApp+971 4 512 8840Disabled
Messages
0
Flat for 3 days
Replies canary
FacebookSilver OakGone quiet
Comments
12
Drifting down all fortnight
Messages
—
Messenger is not wired up
Comments shadowModeration shadow
3 · Status as a band across the top
The state colours a full-width strip above the name. Impossible to miss at a glance across a grid; the loudest, and a healthy channel shouts as much as a broken one.
Receiving
Instagram@silveroakproperties
Comments
116
Highest in two weeks
Messages
34
None of them answered
Comments liveModeration liveDMs off
Disabled
WhatsApp+971 4 512 8840
Messages
0
Flat for 3 days
Replies canary
Gone quiet
FacebookSilver Oak Properties
Comments
12
Drifting down all fortnight
Messages
—
Messenger is not wired up
Comments shadowModeration shadow
4 · Coloured edge, status under the name
A 4px edge carries the state down the whole card and the word sits under the name at normal weight. The state is findable from across the screen without any element shouting.